July 30, 2025

How Do You Recover?

What happens when false accusations upend your entire life so severely that they involve the FBI? For pastor Markus Watson, this nightmare scenario became his reality.

Check out Markus Watson's Website: https://www.markuswatson.com/

DO YOU WANT A SHOUT-OUT ON THE PODCAST? Use one or ALL of these links below

Leave a Message

Support the show

Leave a Voicemail

 

VISIT THE WEBSITE

JOIN THE COMMUNITY!

CHECK OUT THE HCC STORE

 

**Sign up for the mailing list and instantly get my FREE 7-day Devotional**

5 Bible Verses to Memorize to Retrain Your Brain (PDF)

Leave a Review for the Podcast

Leave a Prayer Request


Want to Be a Guest on Honest Christian Conversations?

Are you a Podcast Host in need of a better way to Podcast? RIVERSIDE

00:00 - Accused of Something Egregious

08:42 - The Investigation Begins

16:22 - Finding Worth in Unworthiness

21:40 - The Transformative Moment

27:48 - Resolution and New Beginnings

32:34 - Breaking the Male Ego

WEBVTT

00:00:00.059 --> 00:00:05.192
Have you ever been accused of something so egregious that you almost lost your job for it?

00:00:05.192 --> 00:00:09.150
Maybe you were afraid you were going to go to jail because of this accusation?

00:00:09.150 --> 00:00:15.692
If you resonate with those questions, then you are going to want to hear what Marcus Watson has to say.

00:00:15.692 --> 00:00:35.768
My guest today is a perfect guest to have on at the end of this Tribute to Masculinity series that I have been doing, because he went through such an ordeal as a pastor of a church being accused by someone in his church for something so egregious and his attitude about it, his reflections on it.

00:00:35.768 --> 00:00:37.171
He goes through all of it.

00:00:37.171 --> 00:00:39.246
You are going to enjoy this episode.

00:00:39.246 --> 00:00:40.390
Be so encouraged.

00:00:40.390 --> 00:00:42.567
Welcome to Honest Christian Conversations.

00:00:42.567 --> 00:00:43.723
I'm Anna Murdy.

00:00:43.723 --> 00:00:44.887
Let's get to it.

00:00:44.887 --> 00:00:45.340
Courage.

00:00:45.340 --> 00:00:46.281
Welcome to Honest Christian Conversations.

00:00:46.281 --> 00:00:46.743
I'm Anna Murby.

00:00:46.743 --> 00:00:47.584
Let's get to it.

00:00:47.744 --> 00:00:53.033
Before the episode starts, make sure you follow the show so you never miss another episode.

00:00:53.033 --> 00:01:00.323
Marcus, thank you so much for coming on the podcast to talk with me.

00:01:00.323 --> 00:01:02.466
I heard you talking on the Bleeding Daylight podcast about your story.

00:01:02.466 --> 00:01:31.909
That was an emotional roller coaster, I must say, and that's somebody who is listening to it, so I can only imagine how terrible it was for you to have to go through such a situation, to be accused of such heinous things, and there's no proof of it, but it does mess with people's minds, their thoughts about you, and I'm very excited to talk to you and to uncover all this, especially during my tribute to masculinity.

00:01:31.909 --> 00:01:37.995
I think this is a perfect, perfect conversation to have, because this hits right at that.

00:01:37.995 --> 00:01:39.716
So thank you for coming on.

00:01:40.079 --> 00:01:41.385
Yeah, I'm very glad to be here.

00:01:41.385 --> 00:01:42.349
Thanks for having me.

00:01:42.680 --> 00:01:43.441
Yeah, all right.

00:01:43.441 --> 00:01:49.114
Well, give us a brief overview of the situation.

00:01:49.400 --> 00:01:56.503
It's hard to believe it's been now 10 years ago that it started and it's in some ways it feels like a long time ago.

00:01:56.503 --> 00:01:58.608
In some ways it still feels very fresh.

00:01:58.608 --> 00:02:01.263
My life is still sort of living out.

00:02:01.263 --> 00:02:05.825
I'm still living out the ramifications of all the stuff that happened, both negative and positive.

00:02:05.825 --> 00:02:08.635
So, basically, what happened was about 10 years ago.

00:02:08.656 --> 00:02:16.221
I'm a Presbyterian pastor in San Diego and our executive presbyter asked to meet with me and he came over to my house.

00:02:16.221 --> 00:02:27.425
I was on sabbatical, interestingly at the time, just about two weeks into it, and so he came over and basically said that someone at our church had accused me of having a problem with pornography.

00:02:27.425 --> 00:02:30.667
Now, full disclosure have I ever looked at pornography?

00:02:30.667 --> 00:02:48.004
Yes, however, it's very important for me not to, and so for a long time, I'd had accountability software and accountability partner, and so when those accusations came, I was like, well, okay, you know, I wasn't too worried about it because I knew that there wasn't any, wasn't going to be anything on my laptop.

00:02:48.004 --> 00:02:49.087
There wasn't going to be.

00:02:49.087 --> 00:02:55.532
You know, I would have my accountability partner who'd be able to provide actual evidence of accountability reports.

00:02:55.532 --> 00:02:56.322
You know those kinds of things.

00:02:56.342 --> 00:02:59.169
So I'm like, okay, well, what would you like to do?

00:02:59.169 --> 00:03:03.268
And he said, well, I'd like to take your laptop and have a forensic analyst look at it.

00:03:03.268 --> 00:03:04.912
I was like you want it now?

00:03:04.912 --> 00:03:05.913
He said that'd be good.

00:03:05.913 --> 00:03:12.389
So I gave him the laptop and he had said that it would take a few days and those few days turned into a few weeks.

00:03:12.389 --> 00:03:13.960
So that became kind of frustrating.

00:03:13.960 --> 00:03:25.219
About two or three weeks after he had taken my laptop, he called me and he said well, I can't give your laptop back because it's now a potential criminal investigation.

00:03:25.219 --> 00:03:29.268
And I was like what, what are you talking about?

00:03:29.268 --> 00:03:33.371
And of course I'm thinking like what in the world could they possibly have found?

00:03:33.371 --> 00:03:35.448
I know I didn't put anything illegal on there.

00:03:35.448 --> 00:03:44.067
At the time our tech guy at our church had become, unfortunately, kind of a nemesis and I was like did he put something on there?

00:03:44.067 --> 00:03:44.830
He didn't.

00:03:45.900 --> 00:03:48.810
But I feared that that's where I would have went to.

00:03:49.659 --> 00:03:51.463
Yeah, yeah, well, I wondered that.

00:03:51.463 --> 00:03:53.329
So it wasn't him.

00:03:53.329 --> 00:03:56.764
But I wondered like, okay, did somebody put terrorist stuff on?

00:03:56.805 --> 00:04:00.596
there bomb making instructions or put child pornography on there.

00:04:00.596 --> 00:04:02.841
The accusation was pornography.

00:04:02.841 --> 00:04:04.182
So I'm like, did they put child pornography?

00:04:04.182 --> 00:04:05.305
That was my fear.

00:04:05.305 --> 00:04:08.811
My fear was, is it going to look like I'm guilty of something?

00:04:08.811 --> 00:04:12.383
So that sort of put me into a dark spiral.

00:04:12.383 --> 00:04:18.120
Because, well, one of the problems was that our presbytery wasn't following its due process.

00:04:18.120 --> 00:04:21.449
We have due process in our denomination.

00:04:21.449 --> 00:04:25.744
Our book of order says here are the steps you take if there are accusations and allegations.

00:04:25.744 --> 00:04:31.754
And I was being denied my due process, and so that made me feel really scared.

00:04:31.754 --> 00:04:32.541
To be honest.

00:04:32.541 --> 00:04:34.867
I was like I don't know what to do about this.

00:04:34.867 --> 00:04:36.812
I have no power, I have no control.

00:04:36.812 --> 00:04:38.202
There's nothing that I can do.

00:04:38.202 --> 00:04:41.750
This is a secret investigation that's taking place.

00:04:41.750 --> 00:04:43.225
I was pretty, pretty scared.

00:04:43.264 --> 00:04:46.103
During that time I did have some really great support.

00:04:46.103 --> 00:04:57.904
So one of my best friends, who was also my accountability partner, also a Presbyterian pastor in our Presbytery, really went to bat for me, and so he would have meetings with people that I couldn't have meetings with.

00:04:57.904 --> 00:05:16.742
He made phone calls that I couldn't make, he sent emails that I couldn't send, and so he was really, really supportive, and so what this did, was it kind of brought to light for me, my own sense of unworth, maybe, where I was wrestling with why would they do this to me?

00:05:16.742 --> 00:05:27.584
Because I wasn't in a big church and I was like they wouldn't do it to so-and-so from that big church or so-and-so from that big church, but they'll do it to me from little my church, you know.

00:05:27.584 --> 00:05:33.629
And so it kind of hit me in this place of well, marcus, this is how you get treated.

00:05:33.629 --> 00:05:45.937
It sort of made me feel very unvaluable, unworthy I don't know if those are the best words, but I just didn't feel like I was worth very much, except for the fact that my friend Kevin was really there for me.

00:05:45.937 --> 00:05:48.959
He would text me about every other day how are you doing today?

00:05:48.959 --> 00:05:53.250
He would take me out to dinner every now and then and again, like I said, really go to bat for me.

00:05:53.250 --> 00:05:59.584
And I remember driving home from one of our meetings, just going out to dinner, and I was like man Lord, why is he doing this for me?

00:05:59.584 --> 00:06:00.584
He doesn't have to do this.

00:06:00.925 --> 00:06:04.492
And then I just sort of realized, oh, I feel like I don't deserve it.

00:06:04.492 --> 00:06:05.920
I feel like I don't deserve it.

00:06:05.920 --> 00:06:22.262
And so the next day I went to the beach and I just kind of spent a few hours there and I had come to this realization that I felt like, yeah, this is all sort of affirming in an unhealthy way that I'm unworthy of love and of care and of justice.

00:06:22.262 --> 00:06:30.889
So I just I was praying and I had to start repeating to myself I deserve to be loved, I deserve to be loved, I deserve First of all.

00:06:30.889 --> 00:06:42.415
I started saying, lord, I deserve your love, and not in the sense that I've earned God's love, but as a human being, created in the image of God, right, I'm valuable enough to him, to God, to be loved.

00:06:42.415 --> 00:06:44.656
So I had to use the word deserve.

00:06:44.697 --> 00:06:52.588
Because what I realized for 30 years I'd been telling myself, you know, every time I would pray for forgiveness, I'd say Lord, please forgive me, I don't deserve your love.

00:06:52.588 --> 00:06:55.865
And it was just sort of like a routine thing that I would say.

00:06:55.865 --> 00:07:00.341
And I was like, oh my gosh, I've been telling myself this message that I don't deserve to be loved.

00:07:00.341 --> 00:07:06.103
I know that there are people in the world who would say and lots of Christians probably, who would say well, we don't deserve to be loved.

00:07:06.103 --> 00:07:13.928
I understand, but I'm worthy of it because God said you are worthy of my love because you've been created in my image, so I had to to be loved by people too.

00:07:13.928 --> 00:07:38.625
I deserve to be treated well, I deserve to be treated with kindness and I deserve, in my particular case, I deserve due process because I've been promised it in our book of order and so I deserve that.

00:07:38.625 --> 00:07:39.648
I'm worthy of that.

00:07:39.687 --> 00:07:46.822
And so, anyway, I had to undo this message in my head and that was a very, very healing experience for me.

00:07:46.822 --> 00:07:56.980
So one of the other important, very healing moments was when I met with an attorney, because I didn't have any, I wasn't being given any protections by our denomination, which normally I would have been.

00:07:56.980 --> 00:08:00.670
And so I met with this attorney and I said here's what I'm being accused of.

00:08:00.670 --> 00:08:09.221
And basically she said in the beginning she said, listen, if you're guilty, like of child pornography that's that was my fear Then I'm not going to, I'm not going to represent you.

00:08:09.221 --> 00:08:18.644
But she listened and after about an hour of us just kind of sharing what was going on, she said to me well, I can tell you're not guilty, and I said you can, how?

00:08:18.725 --> 00:08:19.206
can you tell?

00:08:19.605 --> 00:08:21.348
And she said well, you're not asking the right questions.

00:08:21.348 --> 00:08:22.488
I was like what do you mean?

00:08:22.488 --> 00:08:28.836
She said, well, if you were guilty, you'd be asking questions like how much time am I looking at what's our defense gonna be?

00:08:28.836 --> 00:08:32.139
And she said and you're just asking how you can get your laptop back?

00:08:32.421 --> 00:08:40.467
And I was like, oh, Finally someone is there who gets it, that's exactly how I felt.

00:08:40.467 --> 00:08:45.515
That's exactly it I can imagine that that was a very stressful time.

00:08:45.515 --> 00:08:47.682
Were you married at this time?

00:08:47.682 --> 00:08:48.003
Did?

00:08:48.003 --> 00:08:49.466
You have a family.

00:08:49.466 --> 00:08:51.350
Were they supportive as well?

00:08:51.389 --> 00:08:52.131
Yeah, for sure.

00:08:52.131 --> 00:08:59.765
My wife was in that meeting with me, the attorneys with the attorney, and my kids were young so I didn't tell them what was going on.

00:08:59.765 --> 00:09:02.201
My youngest still doesn't really know, he won't listen to this podcast.

00:09:02.221 --> 00:09:03.926
I'll tell him eventually when he's a little bit older.

00:09:03.926 --> 00:09:06.745
I have told my older two and so they know the story.

00:09:06.745 --> 00:09:25.806
Yeah, it was very, very stressful, and yet what I learned is that that's where at least in my experience, I think that that's where God meets us, or where we become the most open to God, god's presence, god's love, god's just being with us.

00:09:25.806 --> 00:09:26.688
I experienced this.

00:09:26.688 --> 00:09:29.966
I had a pretty dark moment, but pretty transformative moment.

00:09:29.966 --> 00:09:32.913
I spent a lot of time in silence.

00:09:32.913 --> 00:09:33.822
I was on sabbatical.

00:09:33.822 --> 00:09:38.120
For the first three months of this I was on sabbatical, so I had a lot of time to myself.

00:09:38.120 --> 00:09:39.462
I'm really grateful.

00:09:39.462 --> 00:09:45.633
I mean, it was kind of a pretty terrible sabbatical because of this, but I can imagine it would be.

00:09:46.153 --> 00:09:54.001
Yeah, but I was also kind of grateful that I didn't have to go to work or come up with sermons and everybody, yeah, see everybody.

00:09:54.042 --> 00:09:55.525
And it's like who?

00:09:55.525 --> 00:09:55.826
Who?

00:09:55.826 --> 00:09:57.049
Yeah the whispers and who?

00:09:57.149 --> 00:09:58.152
who made the accusation?

00:09:58.152 --> 00:09:58.681
I don't know who.

00:09:58.681 --> 00:10:19.230
I had this moment because I spent a lot of time in the scriptures just reading and silence and prayer, and I spent a lot of time in the Psalms of lament Right, and these are the Psalms where the psalmist oftentimes David, who is crying out to God why are you letting my enemies get the better of me and destroy my enemies, and things like that.

00:10:19.251 --> 00:10:22.919
I'm like reading this, I'm like yeah, yeah, that's how I feel I get it.

00:10:22.919 --> 00:10:37.910
Now I was going to ask did you think that you were a little bit like David whenever he was crying out saying avenge me, lord, you know, I'm clean of this absolved of this Absolutely, absolutely.

00:10:38.051 --> 00:10:44.796
Because you know, prior to this it's not like I had really ever had any enemies, but this time I felt like I had enemies.

00:10:44.796 --> 00:10:46.797
I'm like I pain and fear.

00:10:46.797 --> 00:11:04.316
So you cry out to God rescue me, destroy my enemies.

00:11:04.316 --> 00:11:23.096
So I really really appreciated those and I had a moment, after spending time in one of those Psalms, I kind of put my Bible down and I was just kind of sitting quietly and I started thinking about all the worst things that could happen and I thought to myself man, I could lose my job if it looks like I'm guilty.

00:11:23.096 --> 00:11:26.602
And then I thought I could lose my ordination.

00:11:26.602 --> 00:11:32.461
I was like I could lose my reputation and all these people would think this thing is true of me.

00:11:32.461 --> 00:11:33.772
That isn't actually true.

00:11:33.772 --> 00:11:37.902
And then I thought I could lose my family if it looks like I'm guilty of this.

00:11:37.902 --> 00:11:41.461
I don't know, I don't think I would have, but that's where my mind went.

00:11:41.951 --> 00:11:44.158
Yeah, we spiral when things are going bad.

00:11:44.850 --> 00:11:56.235
Yeah, and that's what was happening as I was spiraling and then I thought I could lose my house, I could become a registered sex offender, and everywhere I go I would have to say this thing about myself that isn't true, right?

00:11:56.235 --> 00:12:26.149
No-transcript.

00:12:26.429 --> 00:12:28.916
And I was like oh, oh.

00:12:29.155 --> 00:12:33.934
And all of a sudden I understood God's love in a way that I had never understood it before.

00:12:33.934 --> 00:12:39.172
I had always preached God's unconditional love and taught and believed in God's unconditional love.

00:12:39.172 --> 00:12:40.614
Yeah, God loves me unconditionally.

00:12:40.614 --> 00:12:43.298
Yippee, you know, but it's like.

00:12:44.399 --> 00:12:45.101
It's different.

00:12:45.201 --> 00:12:56.596
It hits different when you experience it, yeah, when you're in the depths like that in the, in the, in the pit, like the psalmist says, the Myrie was a Myrie pit or something like that.

00:12:56.636 --> 00:13:05.356
Myrie clay, yeah, and and all of a sudden it's like, yeah, but you might sink into this pit, but you will never lose my love.

00:13:05.356 --> 00:13:10.894
And you think about Paul who said nothing can separate us from his love, neither height nor depth, right?

00:13:10.894 --> 00:13:17.272
All of that Anyway, that was a transformative moment for me and I would say that that was almost like the turning point of my life.

00:13:17.272 --> 00:13:24.100
I almost kind of think of my life as before that moment and after that moment and it kind of changed everything for me.

00:13:24.100 --> 00:13:29.446
It changed the way I think about God, it changed the way I think about myself, it changed the way I think about other people.

00:13:29.446 --> 00:13:38.934
It changed the way I think about my work as a pastor.

00:13:38.955 --> 00:13:41.710
In other words, I no longer feel like it's my responsibility to get people to believe certain right doctrines.

00:13:41.710 --> 00:13:50.282
I just want people to know that they are God's beloved and if they can begin to believe that about themselves, then God will work out the doctrines.

00:13:50.282 --> 00:13:59.985
I mean I'll still teach what I need to teach, but I'm not going to push people away just because they don't happen to have the same exact beliefs that I do.

00:13:59.985 --> 00:14:01.576
I just want them to know that they're loved.

00:14:01.576 --> 00:14:05.215
I'll conclude my story here, so, before my sabbatical ended.

00:14:05.215 --> 00:14:07.640
So we're like eight or 10 weeks into it.

00:14:07.640 --> 00:14:17.841
At this point I called my executive presbyter and I said well, actually he met with me and he said I just want to let you know that they haven't found anything on my laptop.

00:14:25.970 --> 00:14:29.583
And I was like it's funny, because I didn't react and say, oh hooray, you know, I just kind of I just went okay, yeah, yeah, duh, exactly, that's what it was, that's exactly right.

00:14:29.583 --> 00:14:30.105
But it was a relief.

00:14:30.105 --> 00:14:32.352
I was like, okay, good, well, okay, they know now that there's nothing there.

00:14:32.352 --> 00:14:35.441
Our executive president knows that there's nothing there, yeah.

00:14:35.441 --> 00:14:39.743
And then I was getting ready to go back to work, but I hadn't got my laptop back yet.

00:14:39.743 --> 00:14:41.764
He said it's ready, you can go pick it up.

00:14:41.764 --> 00:14:45.186
And I said okay, great, I'll go pick it up from whoever had it.

00:14:45.186 --> 00:14:49.268
And then my friend Kevin said why don't you talk to your attorney before you go pick it up?

00:14:49.268 --> 00:14:50.110
Just ask her advice.

00:14:50.110 --> 00:14:50.913
And so I did.

00:14:50.913 --> 00:14:56.802
And she said hey, hey, hey, he should not even be talking to you actually, because this is an open investigation.

00:14:56.802 --> 00:14:59.943
As far as we understand right, we haven't gotten any confirmation yet.

00:14:59.943 --> 00:15:04.885
By the way, it was the FBI that ended up with my laptop, and so that was mind blowing.

00:15:05.105 --> 00:15:07.267
My attorney was the one who found that out for me.

00:15:07.267 --> 00:15:13.458
But she said tell him your executive presbyter that he can bring it to my office and you can get it from me.

00:15:13.458 --> 00:15:19.355
And so I emailed him and I said, yeah, this is what my attorney said, because it's still an open investigation.

00:15:19.355 --> 00:15:23.162
And his response was four words Marcus, what investigation?

00:15:23.162 --> 00:15:24.083
And then his name.

00:15:24.083 --> 00:15:25.716
And I was like what?

00:15:25.716 --> 00:15:37.003
And I was so angry because it was like he was pretending that nothing had even happened and I think he was probably protecting himself because he was not following the rules.

00:15:37.003 --> 00:15:39.519
I mean, like I said, the whole due process thing.

00:15:39.519 --> 00:15:44.261
He was not giving me my due process and he could have gotten into big, big trouble for that.

00:15:44.261 --> 00:15:46.251
So anyway, I think he was protecting himself.

00:15:46.251 --> 00:15:49.443
But it made me pretty upset until he got my laptop back.

00:15:49.443 --> 00:16:04.029
But because it was a secret investigation, sort of an under the table investigation, there was no official record of it, and so the person who had made the accusation who I later found out was a staff person at our church, now had the opportunity to make formal allegations.

00:16:04.029 --> 00:16:14.541
So she, she kind of she didn't want to make formal allegations, she's just sort of lobbed the accusation out there, but nothing in writing and then it was sort of taken up in this under the table way.

00:16:14.541 --> 00:16:17.735
But now she's like, well, I can make these formal allegations.

00:16:17.735 --> 00:16:18.518
And so she did.

00:16:18.518 --> 00:16:19.519
And so that kicked off.

00:16:19.519 --> 00:16:26.059
Then an actual formal investigation, following all the rules and the due process and all that.

00:16:26.279 --> 00:16:30.778
And when that news came to me I was just like what again?

00:16:30.778 --> 00:16:33.306
And I was like Lord, what are you doing?

00:16:33.306 --> 00:16:35.530
Why, why are you letting this happen?

00:16:35.530 --> 00:16:36.633
And that lasted.

00:16:36.633 --> 00:16:39.216
I mean, that feeling lasted for an hour or two.

00:16:39.216 --> 00:16:43.965
And then, as I kind of calmed down after the news came, I kind of felt like you know what?

00:16:43.965 --> 00:16:47.018
God, you got me through it once, you'll get me through it again.

00:16:47.018 --> 00:16:48.812
And he did so.

00:16:48.812 --> 00:16:53.090
They did a formal investigation and then I was officially exonerated.

00:16:53.090 --> 00:16:57.802
So I was unofficially exonerated the first time because the FBI said, yeah, there's nothing there.

00:16:57.802 --> 00:16:59.895
Second time I was officially exonerated.

00:16:59.895 --> 00:17:00.879
It's in the record books.

00:17:00.879 --> 00:17:04.740
And then after that the staff person just would not let it go.

00:17:05.349 --> 00:17:08.279
I don't know why she was so adamant about this.

00:17:08.279 --> 00:17:11.089
Vendetta gets you for something petty.

00:17:11.371 --> 00:17:12.215
That is a good question.

00:17:12.215 --> 00:17:24.463
Here's what I do know this staff person said to another staff person, who then told me that she had said I was telling Pastor Marcus about my husband's pornography problem and he just didn't react the way I thought he would.

00:17:24.786 --> 00:17:42.303
I bet he's got a problem with that too, and so, as far as I know, that was the source and she had told me I don't know for sure, but she had told me that there'd been abuse in her past and so maybe some things got triggered in her that led to these accusations and she was just convinced that I was guilty of these things.

00:17:42.303 --> 00:17:51.034
Wow, but yeah, but she, she went to the session which is our board of elders and wrote a letter and made the same allegations again.

00:17:51.034 --> 00:17:54.261
And here's where I had a little another moment of grace.

00:17:54.261 --> 00:17:57.544
I had been keeping a chronology of everything that happens.

00:17:57.544 --> 00:17:59.631
It's like I better, I better keep track of everything.

00:17:59.671 --> 00:18:10.359
So I, I, I had that and I shared it with our session, our elders and my friend Kevin came and he said hey look, I have years worth of accountability reports if you want to see them.

00:18:10.359 --> 00:18:12.854
We had a new executive presbyter by this point.

00:18:12.854 --> 00:18:21.201
The other one had moved to another state and he said as far as the presbytery is concerned, this is a closed matter, so I let the elders talk about it.

00:18:21.201 --> 00:18:27.214
I recused myself for about half an hour, came back and they said Marcus, we want you to know that you have our trust as our pastor.

00:18:27.214 --> 00:18:28.881
I was like awesome, great.

00:18:29.849 --> 00:18:42.060
I didn't say that out loud, but I felt that you know, and then they said and we're not going to ask for your resignation, which was one of the things that was on the table, and we are going to brace for a potential lawsuit from the staff person.

00:18:42.060 --> 00:18:46.246
I was like wow, so they were with me, except for one person.

00:18:46.246 --> 00:18:55.561
One of the elders, for whatever reason, decided that she believed the allegations and she started calling people in the congregation saying Pastor Marcus is into child pornography.

00:18:55.561 --> 00:18:58.054
And I didn't know that.

00:18:58.054 --> 00:19:11.916
Most of us didn't know that at first, the other elders and I but about two weeks later we started hearing that this was going around and when I heard that I was like, oh, I think this is probably the end for me here, because how do you come back from that?

00:19:11.916 --> 00:19:12.178
Right?

00:19:12.730 --> 00:19:14.036
Yeah, it's not easy.

00:19:14.417 --> 00:19:27.439
Yeah, so we had a congregational meeting and somebody made the motion to dissolve the relationship with me that's kind of the Presbyterian language dissolve the relationship between church and pastor and it passed by a margin of two votes.

00:19:27.439 --> 00:19:37.801
I don't think everyone in the church was against me, but what I think is, when you have allegations like that, it's like, well, I don't know if Pastor Marcus did this or not, but let's just play it safe and get a new pastor.

00:19:37.801 --> 00:19:44.455
So that was it for me at that church.

00:19:44.476 --> 00:19:49.737
Interestingly, it actually felt like a huge relief, to be honest, because by that point I think at that point it would because you're just tired of all this.

00:19:50.038 --> 00:19:55.233
Yeah, it had been almost a year, 11 months, and I was just like I'm ready to be gone from here.

00:19:55.233 --> 00:20:09.117
The very next day, I was on a flight to Little Rock, arkansas, for a pastor's week-long retreat, which had been on my calendar for six months already, and I was like, wow, the day after, lord, you knew I was going to need it today.

00:20:09.871 --> 00:20:10.673
He's that good.

00:20:10.974 --> 00:20:11.517
That's right.

00:20:11.517 --> 00:20:12.058
That's right.

00:20:12.058 --> 00:20:14.438
There's nine more years of story after that.

00:20:14.438 --> 00:20:17.159
But never thought I'd be back in church ministry.

00:20:17.159 --> 00:20:18.595
I was like I'm done being a pastor.

00:20:18.715 --> 00:20:19.137
This is it?

00:20:25.470 --> 00:20:26.954
And back in church ministry I was like I'm done being a pastor, this is it.

00:20:26.954 --> 00:20:28.440
And then over time, slowly, God connected me with some really good people.

00:20:28.440 --> 00:20:32.932
I served in a tiny little church in a little town called Westmoreland, two hours east of San Diego, and, like a bunch of farmers, a very agricultural area.

00:20:33.213 --> 00:20:37.040
And they were so good to me and it gave me hope.

00:20:37.040 --> 00:20:40.415
And then, after a few years being there, I came to the church that I'm at now.

00:20:40.415 --> 00:20:45.277
So I've been there for about three years and they're so good too and I feel it's like I feel safe.

00:20:45.277 --> 00:20:48.179
You know, I didn't feel safe after that experience.

00:20:48.179 --> 00:20:51.480
I was like I can't feel safe in churches, but I feel safe again.

00:20:58.250 --> 00:21:03.282
Hey friends, have you joined the Honest Christian Conversations online group yet?

00:21:03.282 --> 00:21:10.270
If you haven't, you're missing out on a perfect opportunity to grow your relationship with Jesus Christ.

00:21:10.270 --> 00:21:15.080
This is a community for those who want to go deeper in their relationship.

00:21:15.080 --> 00:21:26.961
You can do Bible studies together, ask the questions you have biblically and get the answers that you might need or maybe you're somebody who has answers to somebody else's questions.

00:21:26.961 --> 00:21:29.053
You can leave your prayer requests.

00:21:29.053 --> 00:21:31.017
You can leave your praise reports.

00:21:31.017 --> 00:21:33.662
This is a community.

00:21:33.761 --> 00:21:43.534
This is what church is supposed to be, and I am so glad that I finally took that step to make this group so that people's lives can flourish in Jesus name.

00:21:43.534 --> 00:21:50.435
Also, if you haven't signed up for the mailing list, you're missing out on an opportunity there as well.

00:21:50.435 --> 00:21:58.595
I send out a weekly email chocked full of so much awesome content that I don't have time right now to share it all with you.

00:21:58.595 --> 00:22:08.006
But when you do sign up for that mailing list, you get my seven-day free devotional that I created just for those who sign up for the mailing list.

00:22:08.006 --> 00:22:22.256
If you haven't joined either of these, you can go to my website, honestchristianconversationscom and sign up there, or you can use the links for it in the show notes A hard story, but a good ending.

00:22:22.537 --> 00:22:23.820
Yeah, that's good.

00:22:24.351 --> 00:22:28.481
How did this affect you from a masculine point of view?

00:22:28.481 --> 00:22:34.138
I mean to be accused of pornography when you aren't looking at that.

00:22:34.138 --> 00:22:38.244
You are having accountability that proves that you aren't looking at that.

00:22:38.244 --> 00:22:43.114
That alone is an accusation that could mess with a man's ego.

00:22:43.114 --> 00:22:52.340
But on top of that, someone also accusing you of one of the most egregious forms of pornography that has an actual.

00:22:52.340 --> 00:22:54.162
I could go to jail.

00:22:54.162 --> 00:22:56.022
This is going to ruin my reputation.

00:22:56.022 --> 00:22:58.325
I might have to register as a sex offender.

00:22:58.325 --> 00:23:00.567
How did this affect you as a man.

00:23:00.707 --> 00:23:01.627
Wow, that's a good question.

00:23:01.627 --> 00:23:04.680
I've actually never thought of it kind of through that lens before.

00:23:04.680 --> 00:23:12.857
But one of the things that you said, you used the word ego and that's really helpful for me to kind of think about.

00:23:12.857 --> 00:23:14.201
How did it affect me as a man?

00:23:14.201 --> 00:23:16.959
Because I think men do have egos.

00:23:16.959 --> 00:23:19.534
I mean, everybody has an ego, right To one degree or another.

00:23:19.534 --> 00:23:21.019
I think men definitely.

00:23:21.019 --> 00:23:22.553
And I had this.

00:23:22.553 --> 00:23:25.519
I was like, listen, I'm going to take care of this.

00:23:26.760 --> 00:23:36.653
And when I started at this church, I was like man you know, I was in my early thirties, so as I was young, I was still kind of gung ho about all that.

00:23:36.653 --> 00:23:46.125
I was like I'm going to turn this church around, I'm going to make it awesome, I'm going to, I'm going to everybody's going to think I'm super awesome because I've turned this church around.

00:23:46.125 --> 00:23:50.040
You know, people are going to look at me and say, wow, what a great pastor that Marcus Watson is, you know.

00:23:50.040 --> 00:23:54.615
And so I guess now I don't know if that's a specifically masculine thing, but maybe it is.

00:23:54.615 --> 00:23:56.317
I don't know if for women.

00:23:56.317 --> 00:23:59.843
I'm sure there's some women who feel that way as well and some men who don't.

00:24:00.202 --> 00:24:03.268
All the girl bosses are going, yeah, yeah.

00:24:05.452 --> 00:24:20.698
But you know, when this happened and I mean it kind of wrecked my ego because I thought I mean it just made me feel like a failure and I felt like what in the world was all of that for All that hard work?

00:24:20.939 --> 00:24:30.105
And it's not like I was a bad person, I mean I love the people and I love Jesus and I wanted to reach out to our community and we did really good things for our community.

00:24:30.105 --> 00:24:46.403
But that ego part of it was definitely there and this broke my ego and that was the best thing that could have happened for me, because I came through it more secure in who I am, as a man and as a human being and as a child of God.

00:24:46.403 --> 00:24:52.688
I came through it recognizing that the only thing that matters about me it's not what I accomplish, it's not what I achieve.

00:24:52.688 --> 00:24:55.096
It's not what I achieve, it's not what people think about me.

00:24:55.096 --> 00:25:07.294
The only thing that matters about me ultimately I shouldn't say the only thing but the most important thing, far above everything else when it comes to who I am, is that I'm God's beloved and that's it.

00:25:09.117 --> 00:25:17.856
I could fail at everything I do from here on out, it doesn't change a thing about me because I'm God's beloved, right, that's who I am.

00:25:17.856 --> 00:25:34.641
So, yes, the accusations were very male-oriented kind of accusations, but people get accused of stuff all the time, right, whether you're a man or a woman, and it was painful, it was embarrassing, just the thought of it, even though not that many people knew about it, it was embarrassing, just the thought of it, even though not that many people knew about it.

00:25:34.576 --> 00:25:41.123
Yeah, the kind of it was embarrassing that I was potentially going to lose my job and that I did lose my job.

00:25:41.123 --> 00:25:42.814
That was I mean.

00:25:42.814 --> 00:25:49.616
If you want to talk about male ego, I mean that kind of broke my male ego, right, losing my job, and yet I needed that Like the weird.

00:25:49.616 --> 00:25:57.122
This is the weird thing as much as I never, ever, ever, ever, ever want to go through anything like that again, I would not undo it.

00:25:57.142 --> 00:25:58.507
I would go through it again.

00:25:58.507 --> 00:26:02.016
No, I don't want to go through it again but I wouldn't I know what you mean.

00:26:02.256 --> 00:26:18.644
I get it I I have some stuff in my past where I'm like you know I don't really want to go through it again, but I don't want to change things yeah because who knows what would have happened to me and my life and the people in it, had I done things differently.

00:26:18.644 --> 00:26:24.949
So yeah, I get that it's like you want to know, but at the same time you're like, well, I don't want to do that, so yeah.

00:26:25.371 --> 00:26:27.695
And yeah, so, so, yeah, you get it right.

00:26:27.695 --> 00:26:31.992
It's like when you go through hard things like that, it deepens you as a person.

00:26:31.992 --> 00:26:50.647
When you see someone who's never gone through anything hard in their life, or very little, and they've always been in positions of authority, let's say right, and people have always had to do what they tell them to do my opinion, but I think there is a very shallow character, because you've never been through anything hard.

00:26:50.647 --> 00:26:58.603
Right, it is the I mean, I don't remember, is it one of the Timothys perhaps, where it talks about we're crushed but not destroyed.

00:26:58.603 --> 00:27:13.165
But it's the dark times, it's the fear, it's the suffering that actually deepens us as human beings and creates the space in us for God to do that work, to make us fully into who we were created to be from the very beginning.

00:27:13.165 --> 00:27:14.153
And when all you've got is I'm in charge and you got to do that work to make us fully into who we were created to be from the very beginning.

00:27:14.451 --> 00:27:21.578
And when all you've got is I'm in charge and you got to do what I tell you to do, and how dare you say this or that about me?

00:27:21.578 --> 00:27:23.837
I mean, you're just the skin on a person.

00:27:23.837 --> 00:27:24.171
You're not.

00:27:24.171 --> 00:27:25.958
You're not the deepest part of who you are.

00:27:25.958 --> 00:27:31.316
So I think, in some ways, I think we all need to be broken in ways like this, not the same way as me.

00:27:31.316 --> 00:27:33.791
This is what I needed.

00:27:33.791 --> 00:27:40.036
You know, different people need it in different ways, and I think yeah, I've heard it said that we have to make a transition from first half of life to second half of life.

00:27:40.036 --> 00:27:45.196
First half of life is all about building our frameworks and structures and building up our ego.

00:27:45.196 --> 00:27:46.138
We need that.

00:27:46.138 --> 00:27:51.576
We need when we're kids and we're on the swing and we say, hey, look at me, how high I'm swinging.

00:27:51.576 --> 00:27:54.823
And you need parents to say that's so great, you know way to go.

00:27:54.823 --> 00:27:57.468
Look, mom, no hands, awesome, good job, you know.

00:27:57.468 --> 00:28:01.396
But if you're still doing that when you're 50, hey, look at me, look at me.

00:28:01.557 --> 00:28:16.978
Right, you haven't moved on into true spiritual adulthood, and so I think it's these dark times, these hard times, that help us transition from what we might call spiritual childhood to spiritual adulthood, spiritual boyhood to spiritual manhood.

00:28:16.978 --> 00:28:22.525
And spiritual manhood, in my opinion, doesn't get offended, say things about me if you want, that's okay.

00:28:22.525 --> 00:28:23.665
I'm God's beloved.

00:28:23.665 --> 00:28:33.291
Comes anymore because God's got it.

00:28:33.291 --> 00:28:35.175
I don't, like I was saying before, I don't feel the need to control what people believe.

00:28:35.175 --> 00:28:41.659
I don't and I can't control if someone feels loved or not, but I can do what I can do, and so it's just like.

00:28:41.859 --> 00:28:51.617
I love the image in the Old Testament where the people are going through the wilderness and God says to them don't be tight-fisted, be open-handed, and I love those words.

00:28:51.617 --> 00:28:57.184
And it's not just about money, right, tight-fisted and open-handed with money, it's just tight-fisted, it's a posture in life.

00:28:57.184 --> 00:29:03.711
I think before this experience I was very tight-fisted.

00:29:03.711 --> 00:29:19.537
I wanted things to turn out the way I wanted them to turn out, and now I'm like, well, I've got way less control over my life and over the world than I thought I did, and so you just need to go through life being open-handed, which means receiving and giving right, receiving from God, receiving from others.

00:29:19.537 --> 00:29:36.123
Everything is a gift and then sharing open-handedly the gifts that God has given you and who you are and your love for others, well, that has been transformative for me, and I think I'm a way better pastor than I was and I don't say that with any like egotistically, I'm just like I feel like I love people more.

00:29:43.309 --> 00:29:48.069
Yeah, if you could give one piece of advice to men right now who might be going through a difficult season of life, what would you give them advice for?

00:29:48.309 --> 00:29:50.457
Yeah, great question I would say.

00:29:50.457 --> 00:29:54.413
First of all, I would say this is not the end of your story.

00:29:54.413 --> 00:29:56.115
This is a chapter in your story.

00:29:56.115 --> 00:30:00.642
This was something I would have thought about while I was going through this and I would remind myself of that.

00:30:00.642 --> 00:30:02.084
This is not the end of my story.

00:30:02.084 --> 00:30:14.375
This is not the end of my story story and there's going to be a next chapter.

00:30:14.375 --> 00:30:15.823
Right, and that next chapter will be different than this chapter.

00:30:15.823 --> 00:30:18.653
It will have good things and it will have challenging things as well, but it could be really good.

00:30:18.653 --> 00:30:22.079
So I would say, don't give up, don't lose hope.

00:30:22.079 --> 00:30:48.337
And also I would say, just remember that whatever this hard, challenging thing that you're going through right now does not say anything about your value as a human being or as a man, because, again, the most important thing about you is that you are God's beloved, and so, whether you come out of this looking like a great success or looking like a terrible failure I mean, it sucks if you come out looking like a terrible failure- but you know what?

00:30:48.900 --> 00:30:56.000
In the end, we're all terrible failures and we're all loved by God more than we could ever possibly know, and so I don't know.

00:30:56.000 --> 00:30:57.123
That would be my word.

00:30:57.470 --> 00:30:58.913
Very good word for people.

00:30:58.913 --> 00:31:01.999
You have a podcast right.

00:31:01.999 --> 00:31:04.144
Go ahead and share that with us before we go.

00:31:04.430 --> 00:31:04.990
Yeah, for sure.

00:31:04.990 --> 00:31:10.163
So my podcast is called Spiritual Life and Leadership and I started it shortly after this whole experience.

00:31:10.163 --> 00:31:11.166
I was like how do we lead?

00:31:11.247 --> 00:31:12.390
in a healthy, spiritual way.

00:31:12.390 --> 00:31:14.134
Another way God is helping you heal Yep.

00:31:14.556 --> 00:31:17.973
A hundred percent, a hundred percent, and so, anyway, spiritual Life and Leadership.

00:31:17.973 --> 00:31:24.040
Right now I'm doing it in partnership with Fuller Seminary's Church Leadership Institute, and so we talk a lot about adaptive leadership on there as well.

00:31:24.040 --> 00:31:37.696
But some really great conversations with great people, and I'll point you to my book too, beyond Thingification, which came out after this experience too, and it's just a way to reach out to your neighbors as a church without objectifying them.

00:31:37.696 --> 00:31:39.998
In other words, hey, these are real people, and how do you reach?

00:31:40.018 --> 00:31:43.039
out to these real people in your neighborhoods, yeah, oh, that's good.

00:31:43.660 --> 00:31:47.902
So where can people get this resource and listen to your podcast?

00:31:48.461 --> 00:31:49.942
So you can listen to the podcast.

00:31:49.942 --> 00:31:51.784
Of course, anywhere you listen to podcasts.

00:31:51.784 --> 00:31:54.164
You can go to my website, marcuswatsoncom.

00:31:54.164 --> 00:31:59.067
That's Marcus with a K K-U-S Watson, and then the book is on Amazon.

00:31:59.067 --> 00:32:00.167
You can find that on Amazon.

00:32:00.228 --> 00:32:00.708
Wonderful.

00:32:00.708 --> 00:32:08.201
Thank you again, marcus, for coming on and recounting this dark but also very encouraging story for us.

00:32:08.623 --> 00:32:09.284
Yeah, thank you.

00:32:09.284 --> 00:32:11.217
I appreciate getting to share my story.

00:32:24.181 --> 00:32:25.122
Thanks for listening.

00:32:25.122 --> 00:32:26.663
If yeah, thank you.

00:32:26.663 --> 00:32:28.124
I appreciate getting to share my story.

00:32:28.124 --> 00:32:33.088
Honestchristianconversationscom to leave a review or feedback as well.

00:32:33.088 --> 00:32:36.594
Join the community and become part of something bigger than yourself.

00:32:36.594 --> 00:32:42.291
Lastly, sign up for the mailing list and get the free seven-day devotional as a thank you gift.

00:32:42.291 --> 00:32:44.473
Once again, thanks for listening.

00:32:44.473 --> 00:32:46.854
I look forward to our next conversation.

Markus Watson Profile Photo

Markus Watson

Helping Christian leaders lead in a healthy way

I'm the host of Spiritual Life and Leadership, the official podcast for Fuller Theological Seminary's Church Leadership Institute.

In 2021, I released my first book, Beyond Thingification: Helping Your Church Engage in God's Mission, which helps churches and leaders more fully participate in God's mission in the world.

I often speak about the role of suffering in spiritual and leadership formation. Several years ago, I was falsely accused and voted out of my congregation. It was a terribly painful experience, but it made me a healthier and more whole person, pastor, and leader.

I'm also a pastor of a small church in rural Southern California which has a vibrant Food Pantry ministry serving a town that struggles with a lot of food insecurity.